Primist

Reader's Comments

1. Hossein | May 26th, 2008 at 5:07 am

   Not true
   Anyway, have a look at this article:
   http://www.roozonline.com/archives/2008/05/post_7551.php

2. Shimoel | May 26th, 2008 at 6:56 am

   Mister Hossein who simply says “Not true”, can you explain please? The link you gave is in Arabic/Urdu/Farsi (not sure). I have read Economist’s article and have followed the crisis in the past 6-8 months. It seems true to me! Nasrallah has gained whatever he has wanted in the last few years, effectively since kicking Israel out of south Lebanon.

3. Hossein | May 26th, 2008 at 1:24 pm

   Shimoel, the article I linked here is in Farsi. This article was for Ali. But anyway it says (provides reference documents) that the people of Lebanon
   -unlike Nasrallah- did not win this battle (SO I SAID IT IS NOT TRUE THAT PEOPLE OF LEBANON WON) and also gave some documents on how other forces impacted the battle.

4. Ali | June 9th, 2008 at 9:07 am

   Hossein, the article you gave did not properly reference its claims at all. Even if it did, it does not cover the whole story and its aspects, but only the bits which benefits the author’s enmity with the Islamic Republic.

5. Hossein | June 10th, 2008 at 6:02 am

   علی جان
   من تا حال مقالات زیادی برات فرستادم و خیلی دوست داشتم که فرصتی میشد تا باز هم باهم صحبت کنیم
   در مورد این مطلب باید بگم
   من نمیدونم چرا هر بجای قبول واقعیتها میزنیم تو صحرای کربلا و همه چیز رو ربط میدیم به دشمن و دشمنی
   همیشه همینطور بوده
   سو مدیریت و خیانت رو ربط میدن به دشمن
   و هر کس هم حرف حساب میزنه بخاطر دشمنی با نظام تعبیرش میکنیم
   مثلا همین فیلم جدیدی که از صدر تا ذیل نظام رو به فساد مالی متهم میکنه؛ اینکه دیگه از خودیاست
   باز هم دشمن داره نظام رو تضعیف میکنه؟
   اگر ندیدیش اینجا ببینش
   http://www.archive.org/details/efshaghari
   درضمن سفر خوبی داشته باشی
   در تماس باش

6. Ali | June 10th, 2008 at 8:02 am

   Hossein Jan, I don’t have a Farsi keyboard here with me. When did I say I don’t accept that nasty issues are going on in the country? I certainly agree, but on the true ones.
   Anyway. it’s not about a particular political party I’m supporting, it’s the core of the regime I beleive in, not everything happening in it. If everything was right and fine, why are we in Melbourne right now?!
   The issue with us is that we see things only either black or white, zero or one, no colours or numbers within between… If I support an activity of the regime or the government, people say you’re supporting all they do including wrong ones, and if you say something against them, I’m gonna say your against everything. When I speak about a certain topic, people will bring on other topics to argue, in this way none of the discussions will finish and all we do is just touching few subjects with no or minimum outcome.
   What I said here is that I agree with the Economist that Nasrollah has won, and I still do. What do I have to do with Palizar right now in this page?
   But now that you’ve raised this, I watched the clip about a week ago, (here are some reactions on it: http://tabnak.ir/pages/?cid=12019 and http://tabnak.ir/pages/?cid=11985 ) he didn’t give proper references on his claims, but however some bits might be true. Ahmadinejad was saying this since the first he came in that Baba, there are big shots who are swallowing everythign and are rast rast walking and everyone were saying that he’s trying to raise more votes for himself and bluffing. If that is true, all of us as people of Iran want those mentioned names to go to courts, if guilty; get punished nomatter who they are and in what position they are placed in, even if these names are not true, there are other ones for sure doing these stuff and worst, and again we all want them to get punished asap, this will just be the start of what we want to happen, justice, the reason of this revolution. If we are now far away from the principals, it doesn’t mean those principals are wrong.
   Ghorbanat

Leave a Reply